Carlo's Bakery Westbury Menu

Carlo's Bakery has operated in Hoboken, New Jersey since 1910 and was taken over by the Valastro family in 1964. It gained national fame through Buddy Valastro's TLC series Cake Boss and now has locations in several states plus nationwide shipping.

14 signature items across 4 categories. Chain menus vary by location and season, so the Garden City store may not carry every item.

Italian Pastries

Lobster TailHand-pulled flaky dough baked golden and filled with Carlo's signature French cream, dusted with powdered sugar.
Classic CannoliCrisp shell filled with sweetened ricotta cream, bittersweet chocolate chips and a touch of cinnamon.
Chocolate-Dipped CannoliTraditional ricotta cannoli with shell ends dipped in chocolate, a popular variation on the classic.
SfogliatellaShell-shaped pastry of paper-thin crisp layers filled with ricotta cream and dusted with powdered sugar.

Signature Cakes

Rainbow CakeBest-selling six layers of rainbow-colored vanilla cake filled with vanilla icing and covered in rainbow sprinkles.
Red Velvet CakeRed velvet layer cake, also sold by the slice and among the shop's most-ordered items.
Carrot CakeLayered carrot cake with cream cheese icing, part of the bakery's best-seller lineup.
Tiramisu CakeIndividual-style tiramisu cake bordered with ladyfingers and filled with soft coffee-flavored cream.
Black & White CakeChocolate and vanilla layer cake from the shop's core lineup of celebration cakes.
Custom Celebration CakesMade-to-order decorated cakes for weddings and occasions, the specialty that made Cake Boss famous.

Check the hoursSee if Carlo's Bakery Westbury is open right now Get directions946 Old Country Rd More italian bakeriesCompare with others near you

Carlo's Bakery Westbury Garden City Menu

Italian Pastries

Signature Cakes

Cookies & Treats

Savory